Response to a comment on WOWHOLFG

stevewhitmire.website

Comment: on WOWHOLFG 

If everything you say here is granted as true – what’s the solution? How does one right the ship? Accepting ALL perceived missteps to date as in the past – what should the folks behind The Muppets do NOW, in the present, to get back on track? – Edmund

Great question.  A train doesn’t just step off the tracks and lose its way; it tears them to pieces, twisting the rails, tearing up the ties, and warping the iron into useless ribbons, permanently altering the track so the original journey can never be made again — even if new steel is laid, you can never ride the same line twice.

There would have to be an altered consensus as to what ‘being on track’ means, a radical acceptance of reckoning, and that will not happen. Present-day folks are ‘on track’ to reach their own destination.  Whether producers or performers, they’re the fans who have become the new versions of the Muppets entirely free of the constraints of taking into account the genesis spirt of the originators.  In their minds that is completely acceptable, and there is no one to tell them otherwise. 

In short, none of them are asking your question because no one requires it to be asked and it does not serve their agenda.  They lack a willingness to understand and accept the true definition of evolution since it could ‘expose the puppet master’, so to speak, through unmasking usurpation.

Alternately, if ‘being on track’ means having Jim Henson’s creations (both the characters and the environment in which they flourish) infused with his influence (the driving force behind the homeostasis) working NOW, within the present, it requires a realistic look at the resulting effects of the ‘missteps.  They can not simply be ‘accepted as being in the past’ since they directly correlate with the present poor circumstances.  Upon that examination it becomes obvious that the runaway train will not be stopped because it serves the motivated reasoning of the players.

The source is gone, and all still involved are only willing to chase the fading ghost of what used to be there, an echo in an empty canyon.  With the last of Jim’s closest vocal disciples ignored and cast out, along with a prevalent attitude of dissociating them from the modern vanguard, what should now be done has become an unattainable imperative.

Perhaps Keats said it best:

“Do not all charms fly

At the mere touch of cold philosophy?

Philosophy will clip an Angel’s wings,

Conquer all mysteries by rule and line,

Empty the haunted air, and gnomed mine—

Unweave a rainbow, as it erewhile made

The tender-person’d Lamia melt into a shade.”*

 

Simply said, it’s just too late…the rainbow is unwoven.

 

 

* https://www.litcharts.com/poetry/john-keats/lamia.  The famous statement in John Keats‘s Lamia—“Do not all charms fly / At the mere touch of cold philosophy?”—means that logical, data driven, scientific, or analytical thinking destroys the beauty, magic, and wonder of the world.

Comments

  • November 12, 2026
    Amanda

    Well said Steve! The rainbow may be unwoven and the ride may have ended but it was a great one! I believe it can still be treasured and kept together in memories that stay alive foreve. A light that shines on and lives in the hearts of those who believe in the magic and hold on to the hope in there hearts.

    reply
  • November 14, 2026
    Andrew Kay

    Well, the era of the original performers and originator-driven consistency for the Muppets is apparently coming to an end. What’s next?

    Thinking of analogies, here are several models for the comedy/variety show continuation that come to mind:

    1) Monty Python, which simply wound down after going through the ‘show to movies’ cycle (they gave one more final performance in 2014, same people minus one), and thus kept the original essence of the show pristine.

    2) SNL, which is continuously going thru all those stages and generations, reinventing itself. SNL now is a completely different show from SNL of Mike Myers era, and that was also different from the Blues Brothers period. Speaking of SNL, it’s interesting that i’m not the only person to compare Muppets to SNL lately, thinking about how the new generations of performers take the whole thing in completely different directions. However, the main difference with the Muppets here, on SNL there is no active character claiming to be Chevy Chase these days, so they are free of contingency restrictions — whereas Disney, having paid big bucks for the rights to character names, will not let Kermit go easily.

    3) Reboot/revival/continuation mode. A number of shows gets rebooted every year, so we have a lot of good and bad references here. However, any good reboot of the show that actually lasts uses evolution of the characters instead of nostalgic time-freeze recaps, and also needs to have some new purpose, something new to say in order to exist. Interesting that reading any number of critique articles on successful and failed reboots comes up to the same things that Steve talks about in his blog — building on the true core of the originals, using character evolution instead of character betrayal, while at the same time adding new emotional weight instead of just replaying the old stuff.

    Speaking of that, the character lineage succession method ultimately gives the Muppets best chance for the real continuation and proper evolution of the characters to happen, under favorable conditions. Unfortunately it requires a great deal of selfless devotion to the originals and full support from everyone involved, something apparently missing in the current setup. (Otherwise they wouldn’t have fired Kermit, right?) So, tragic as it is, this approach is currently out of the picture.

    4) Tribute mode. Nostalgic time-freeze recaps are perfectly fine here, their raison d’etre is to remind people how great the original stuff was. The only thing, these do require scarcity, and have to be one-time performances rather than an ongoing continuation of the show, not to overstay their wistful public welcome. The occasional Hollywood Bowl / O2 performances and the yearly Muppet specials are the perfect examples of this.

    5) Continuation via commodification. The Mickey Mouse, Tom and Jerry, and Commedia dell’Arte approach. The train-jumping pistol-swinging Hercule Poirot of Kenneth Branagh movies is another good example of the same. The problem here is, when characters are treated as the roles open for reinterpretations, there is no way to safeguard the complexity and individuality of the original work. The characters exist as ideas rather than actual living souls. This change could be drastic for the Muppets, since being true to originals is the key to their extraordinary popularity so far, as well as the main reason why Kermit (so far) is invited to graduation ceremonies as a guest of honor, while Mickey Mouse, Elvis, and Spider-Man are not.

    As i understand, the Muppets Tonight was something of an attempt to make the Muppets follow the SNL paradigm above, adding ‘fresh blood’ to the show by introducing new characters, the most natural way to continue across generations. Unfortunately, it stopped after two seasons, before the approach could really soak in with the public.

    Sesame Street, in my opinion, also follows the SNL model with more success, shifting the focus to Elmo (masterfully reimagined by Ryan Dillon), Abby Cadabby and Rosita, and changing its format.

    However, trying to SNL-ize the show into new directions while keeping all the same characters necessarily becomes either reboot or tribute instead — or commodification. Choosing between reboot and tribute modes is the likely cause of their “difficulties cracking a premise” cited as the reason for the Muppet Show revival being held off (while nobody is willing to call what happens a commodification).

    The same issues apparently haunt the latest series of Muppet Walmart commercials, styled as the revival of Muppet Christmas Carol.
    While with the modern AI frame enhancing technology everything looks picture-perfect, to quote people on reddit:

    ‘I fear my thoughts on the Muppets are getting closer to my thoughts on Star Wars. I don’t know or care what’s considered canon nowadays, I just know that Disney screwed it up and I’m largely done caring about the new stuff.
    …With some minor exceptions, it all feels so corporate and forced. Haunted Mansion was fun, but the 2026 special felt too… SNL-esque. Ironically, Maya Rudolph was the most Muppet-feeling part. That and the Gonzo bit. The 2015 show had its moments, but not enough for me to say I liked the whole show. Same with Muppets Mayhem and even Most Wanted. And I don’t think we even need to discuss Muppets Now.
    …Basically, I understand the common sentiment that we need to support the new stuff even if it’s not great so that they keep putting out more with the hope that it’ll get better, but I’m just out of patience for that. IMO it’s been over a decade since a truly great project (I liked the 2011 film a lot), and I’m just ready to move on’.

    reply
    • November 14, 2026
      Steve Whitmire

      Great insights, as always, Andrew….

      3. I would add: “Otherwise they wouldn’t have fired Kermit (over standing up to protect the integrity of the entire enterprise) , right?”

      But all my talk about ‘linear passage’ is ultimately moot because the opportunity for that to occur is the victim of willful blindness and status quo bias as it fast approaches becoming impossible. The tragedy is that any notion of the Lineage is not only currently out of the picture, but it will remain out of the picture since there will soon be no one left to complete its passage.

      4. On your number 4 “Tribute Mode”, I would add that despite their ‘public welcome’ they cross over into the number 2 “SNL” example in that a sincere tribute presented as such does not claim or fail to be the original. A tribute is a sort of ‘loving reminder’ rather than an attempt to convince you that what you are witnessing is the genuine article. The occasional appearances that you mention were fully intended to be the real thing, and because they so heavily capitalize on the past success of the real thing, we have the IGAMA crowd. And that’s completely fine for today’s executives and performers. But if you seek the depth of what Jim brought about, it will always fall short as fully illegitimate. The Walmart MCC commercials are a perfect example of this – nothing new or novel while resting on the laurels of the past to sell us things by appealing to our surface emotions. The ‘tribute band’ strikes again…

      5. On your number 5, “Choosing between reboot and tribute modes is the likely cause of their “difficulties cracking a premise” cited as the reason for the Muppet Show revival being held off (while nobody is willing to call what happens a commodification)” I will add that there is a rumor of deep tension within the seemingly endless line up of ‘executive producers’ on the most recent incarnation….if true, that’s the product of ‘too many cooks none of whom have the original recipe’, a dynamic I witnessed again and again.

      Re:the Reddit comment, I would say to this person:
      Your insight has grown beyond the depth of what’s currently being offered, yet you’re still expected to settle for less, and you see that. Bravo!

      reply
  • November 14, 2026
    Sandee Hysong

    I was heartbroken when Disney took away Muppets 3D because it was the last thing Jim Henson worked on. I went a couple of years ago on my 40th Birthday to see the show again and eat at Pizza Rizzos. I’m glad my kids got to see the show and they loved it. Jim Henson’s hand print is still in front of Mickey’s Runaway.The Muppet Rockin Rollercoaster looks amazing! They also have a Muppet store again! I haven’t seen one since 2011. Disney is honestly trying to keep the Muppets alive and going. It is different,I haven’t really enjoyed any of the new material but at least we have them still around.

    reply

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

stevewhitmire.website
error: Content is protected !!