A.I.ming at Understanding
There’s nothing like being thrown into the deep end with spectators on the sidelines rooting for you to drown as you’re being chased by sharks…I’ve learned more about A.I. in the last week than I could ever care to know. I’d like to share a few conclusions.
But let me first say this:
• The thumbnail in question was from an original sketch I did heavily doctored in Affinity Photo using numerous filters and layers. I do not consider myself to be a sketch artist any more than I am a whiz at image editing, but I am occasionally able to actually produce a decent representation of what is in my mind on an old fashioned paper sketch pad. I fiddle and play until I get something satisfies my eye.
Images were added, both from my own photos, and from internet sources that I often use like Pexels, Pixabay, Adobe Stock, etc., and some elements were added directly using the tools in the app. If any of them started out as something generated by A.I., I have no idea.
So, those conclusions I mentioned:
• First, the genie is out of the bottle, folks, and nobody asked us what we thought before popping the cork. A.I. is here to stay and no amount of protest will change that.
For that reason, as an originator, I believe that now is not the time to take a radical stance shouting “No, A.I.!”, because it will simply do no good. What is needed (on this topic, as well as most polarized issues…) is to get ahead of the negative usages by differentiating without dissociating. In other words, tease apart the details of A.I. and compromise by making distinctions between the various potential usages before condemning the whole enchilada…did I mention that A.I. ain’t goin’ nowhere?
For instance, if you are someone who uses a pencil to get what you see in your mind onto paper (especially when your sketch is to be used as a template design to be used as a guide for something to be built by a true artisan) you are not using A.I. to create an original work – your own creative mind did that on paper – but it might be a useful tool to refine what you, as an artist, created. You might not have a staff, or the resources to hire someone to refine your sketched design before handing it off to a manufacturer (I certainly don’t).
While I am not in favor of having A.I. do our thinking for us, it may be that it offers highly effective functions that do little more than assist legitimate artists in creating what is in their mind’s eye enabling them to convey their vision to those who will be a part of tangibly creating it.
• Second, publicly attacking someone (particularly someone who may have stumbled into the technology, perhaps even unknowingly…) is a demonstration of something commonly known as “Argument as War”.
Virtually everyone I have encountered face-to-face over the last few days has strongly advised me in no uncertain terms that I should ignore each and every one of you who seek to engage in this level of mentality. It is characterized by a fight-or-flight response of righteous indignation where anger is fueled by the belief that one’s own stance is morally superior, making compromise feel like a betrayal of values, a so-called “bunker mentality” where a person refuses to validate any outside information as they stay dug into their polarized stance.
Digital environments alter human brain chemistry and social behavior. When people sit behind a screen, the psychological barriers that normally keep cruel behavior in check completely break down. When people see others being hostile without punishment, social contagion (aka mob mentality) causes them to copy the bad behavior. Social media platforms push their angry posts because they get more views and clicks. It’s called ‘algorithm reinforcement’.
When bad actors go online, the environment of anonymity acts as a catalyst to activate pre-existing psychological vulnerabilities and dark personality traits. Termed “everyday sadists”, these folks derive psychological pleasure and entertainment from causing (or even attempting to cause) emotional distress, humiliation, or confusion to strangers. The internet gives them a low-risk playground to find that enjoyment. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10535633/
Sound familiar? It’s perhaps the biggest problematic issue we face in our culture today. And in this case-in-point, these righteous people seem to justify their callous behavior calling themselves ‘artists’ and ‘Muppet fans’, declaring that they are the authorized proxy for all thing Jim Henson, a man around whom they have fallen victim to the myth they have created in their minds, an altogether entirely ridiculous notion.
• I did a little experiment by using an A.I. detector to analyze a Drew Struzan original poster. The A.I. detector was convince that it was A.I. generated…
And if you brag about how your A.I. detector is a flawless means of saying ‘Gotcha!’, be very clear that you, yourself, are using A.I. to detect A.I. so that you can then turn around and denounce A.I..
• Instagram, Facebook, Tik Tok, You Tube, and all the rest extensively use A.I. (and the associated data centers) 24/7 for numerous purposes throughout their platforms. Anyone and everyone whose eyes have seen the thumbnail image on my Instagram post used, and is supporting the use of, A.I. in the world today.
If you are a “No A.I.” advocate, close down all of you social media immediately. Otherwise, get on board with learning two things: compromise, and (more importantly) empathy.
• I find that most people across the political spectrum care about the environment to some degree on an individual human level even if their reasoning is self focused. But, the mob mentality mentioned above can begin to kick in when they gather as a group behind the moniker of a corporation for which they work. Often they can grow narrow-minded in perpetrating the business agenda of the corporation as they simply do their jobs. When people get so wrapped up in accomplishing a task they can lose perspective on all the various points of view in play.
There are, in fact, corporations with the goal of creating neutral impact data centers designed to balance their resource consumption and carbon footprint so they cause zero net harm to the local environment and energy grid. These facilities plan to match their electricity demand using 100% renewable energy or hourly carbon-free power, operate using advanced liquid cooling or closed-loop systems to achieve water neutrality and prevent local scarcity, capture physical heat byproduct energy and route it to warm nearby homes, offices, or greenhouses, and repair or reuse server materials aiming for zero waste sent to landfills.
https://www.climateneutraldatacentre.net/
Rather than joining an ‘angry mob carrying its pitchforks’ who will never effect the outcome, it might be a more realistic option (since A.I. isn’t going away…) to do some research, think for yourself, and consider speaking out in support of corporations committing to these better practices so that they rise to the top of the murky lake as you help to hold them accountable for what they are saying they will do.
• My own instinct is not to be drawn into having to defend anything to anyone. I owe no explanations or proof of anything related to my creative process, nor does any other true artist.
Understand that I did not originate the data represented in the other post. None of it was written specifically about the Muppets, but about a much bigger and concerning social and cultural issue. It’s compiled from researched and widely acknowledged scientific understandings and theories from sources too numerous to list.
If you presently have no room for its consideration within your cognition, I respectfully suggest that you seek to broaden the scope of your understanding in the very way for which Jim Henson’s approach allowed.
It’s telling that 99% of those commenting have absolutely nothing to say about the content of the paper, only their mistaken beliefs about the method of delivery of the thumbnail, which they fervently spread like a troll virus. When we only look viscerally at the surface of such a complicated social issue we become the very subject of the dossier, itself.
My hope for our world is that everyone can open their minds to being challenged, to the understanding that the mindset in which you have come to rest might be partial.
This isn’t about my caring what you think – I don’t – it’s about caring that you’re thinking. It’s good to see that many of you are.

Amanda
Steve,
Thank you for speaking up about the recent Instagram post regarding the ai situation. I appreciate you writing this and informing me on AI as well.
I know alot of unwanted opinions were jammed down your throat recently and it’s not easy to stomach all that negativity. I’m sorry that happened to you. You don’t deserve that kind of disrespect. Noone does.
I think you handled it the smart way! Kudos to you for doing your research and digesting all this new information on AI and educating yourself on the subject to get the facts.
Just remember, you don’t owe anyone an explanation or proof. The “proof” is your word. Period. Take it or leave it. I like that you don’t care what others think of you because their opinion isn’t important. It’s best to just ignore negative people.
The point of the thumbnail photo was to draw the attention of the audience to your article by using a photo you created with a photo editing program similar to photo shop. By combining your own original artwork and sketches along with select internet photos to create the desired vision that you had in your mind, all to make your point.
That’s not AI.
For people to criticize you because they don’t agree with the photo you used in your post is wrong. It’s important to remember not to judge a book by its cover. To judge it by the ‘three hands holding the crown’ and immediately labeling it as ai based on looks is unfair. Despite you commenting on how you used sketches and drawing you peiced together in photo shop along with photos from the internet. I don’t know how many times you have to keep stressing it.
I will say this. With all do respect, the internet photos may or may have not been ai photos. We don’t know for sure. However even if they were ai generated photos, you didn’t generate them and surely you had no idea they were ai photos in the first place. Listen, everyone makes mistakes. Noone is perfect. We are only human afterall. Plus, you already apologized for it. You didn’t have to apologize for something you didn’t even know about in the first place but you did and I respect that. I honestly don’t know what more people want at this point.
This whole picking on Steve thing and jumping down Steve’s throat every time he posts an article has got to stop! It’s so disrespectful to not only Steve but the entire Muppet community and it’s unacceptable behavior that shouldn’t be tolerated anywhere.
These so called “Muppet fans” who preach the word of Jim about loving and forgiving while attacking and bullying the very man Jim hired? Steve of all people? Steve who is always such a kind man to his fans? Truly a beacon of light in the Muppet community to many. Ashame he he doesn’t always get the same kindness in return.
Do you really think Jim would of liked that? I think not! Jim would of never approved of bullying anyone by any means.
Also, to say that Jim wouldn’t of used ai is irrelevant here. Noone knows for sure what Jim would of used if he was still alive today and just because a fan thinks they know Jim doesn’t mean they get to speak for him because noone can speak for Jim except Jim himself, however since Jim isn’t here to defend himself in this situation. Let’s all please stop putting his name out there and kindly leave Jim out of this whole situation that he isn’t even involved with to began with.
Secondly, read the article again. This isn’t even about Jim or the Muppets entirely. This is an article Steve published that’s important to him. This isn’t something Jim is involved with. It’s something Steve published. Don’t need any immature, troll behavior from cowards who feel safer bullying a Muppet Performer while hiding behind an electronic device (one that uses electricity fueled by fossil fuels) only to complain about the use of AI and it’s impact on the environment.
Plus, using an ai detector that’s not even accurate and uses ai to detect ai? Isn’t that the pot calling the kettle black?
Instead of discussing the situation and talking to you like an adult, some people are too immature to do that. Knowing very well that you eat people like them for breakfast and can easily handle it.
However, it’s much easier to get attention from an online audience on a social media platform where the majority tends to blindly follow the crowd like a herd of sheep in a line and doesn’t have the mantitly to decide or think for themselves.
It’s not worth your time or energy Steve. You’re the bigger person here for stepping up to the plate and researching ai for yourself to educate yourself on the matter. Hey, at least you are contributing something positive to the world through your artwork and your original sketches. Affinity and photo shop are great photo editing tools to help an artist create a photo by combining images together to create the desired look they want. That’s something ai can’t produce because ai isn’t human it can’t think like a real human being.
Ai can’t read minds and has no way of knowing what you are trying to create. Real artists like you think outside the box by using different methods of editing tools to bring to life a vision that’s in their head. This gets people thinking and that’s what real art is all about. When you accomplish that then you succeed.
I suggest if someone doesn’t have anything nice to say then don’t say it at all. If you don’t like something someone posts politely disagree and kindly move on.
That being said. Thank you Steve! I wish you well!
Jocelyn Stevenson
Thanks for this piece, Steve. I particularly appreciated the link to climate neutral data centre – as my biggest objection has been their profligate use of water – and it’s great to know that there are potential solutions. As you say – research! xx
Evan
“ And in this case-in-point, these righteous people seem to justify their callous behavior calling themselves
‘artists’ and ‘Muppet fans, declaring that they are the authorized proxy for all thing Jim Henson, a man around whom they have tallen victim to the myth they have created in their minds, an altogether entirely ridiculous notion.” Hey isn’t this like your whole MO the last few years? I’m not trying to be a dick but I don’t think you understand the concerns these people were bringing up. Not to mention you saying how we should be nicer online feels again ironic with all your callout posts the last few years. I’m not trying to gotcha or whatever but man if every other blog post you make you have to explain how people interpreted it wrong maybe just take a step back and hold off
Steve Whitmire
Thanks for your comment, Evan.
Please understand that I didn’t flippantly disregard the “concerns these people were bringing up”, something that I never do (too my own detriment). Nor did I do what most people would do in my position, which is to entirely and altogether ignore what they were saying by not engaging with them at all. I took a week to fully research the very issues they expressed to get a better understanding of their ‘concerns’.
My posts are not intended to be “callous”. They have been direct, truthful, and objective responses to people who have specifically asked for my opinions. They ask because they recognize that I spent nearly forty years at the core of a franchise that is now in serious decline, likely beyond any hope of ever recovering again. As a result of the level of my commitment and involvement I’ve had a lot of experience standing toe-to-toe with owners and executives whose primary motivation differs entirely from anything that would give the Muppets continued longevity in the way that we achieved with Jim. They either don’t get it, or even worse, begin to see it but refuse to change direction.
I have not said that anyone needs to be “nicer”. I have instead sought to explain why they are not being nice. There is far more to this than the issue of A.I.
My response here – and it is a response – is to hundreds of mean-spirited posts, a cyber lynching based solely on their presumptions about my supposed usage of A.I. to create a thumbnail for a post. In so doing, almost all of them say nothing about the very real issues discussed in the post, itself. That’s because the content unintentionally describes them.
I spend very little time in my life giving any attention to social media, and am not compelled to defend ANYTHING to anyone online, but because in this case the mob mentality was so heinous in nature, and because their assumptions that led to the attack were completely wrong (going well beyond constructively commenting about A.I. on my Instagram page all the way to creating new posts on their own pages designed to perpetuate their lie), I chose to respond.
BTW, their behavior is called ‘libel’.
I am not responsible for how people interpret what they read – they are. There is a difference between “explain how people interpreted it wrong”, and clarifying issues for those who clearly didn’t digest the point. The former is to call them ‘wrong’. The latter is to endlessly work towards an understanding even with people who choose to be ‘bad actors’.
What you have to understand about me, Evan, is that I have one very specific “MO” (aka agenda), the goal of which came into focus in 1990. It is the same consistent goal that has driven everything I have said and done in connection with the Muppets within every setting since that time. It is the filter through which I run every notion.
That goal is to do all that I can to insure that Jim Henson’s influence be kept a living, evolving part of what he created. Bottom line: If you ask me about a topic that concerns the work that we created with Jim Henson you’re going to get a straight and honest response.
This has been quite the little social experiment.
Maalik Naiem
With all due respect, Steve, you are hardly an objective source for many of the things you been arguing on this blog during this year. You have used Jim’s name to justify throwing Matt under the bus, and even deflect away from addressing the criticism from your own former colleagues, some of whom who have called out the contradictions in your own version of events. You have been dismissive of addressing constructive criticisms from anyone, including Marni Hill, someone who really went of her way to bat for you back in 2017.
I am not defending fans who have been rude to you, and I don’t care whether you did use AI or not; but this doesn’t excuse what are you doing, and it is not up to you to decide who the Muppets fans are. I’m not happy with how Disney has handled the Muppets, but you are not helping things at all.
Steve Whitmire
With all due respect, Steve, you are hardly an objective source for many of the things you been arguing on this blog during this year.
I can see why you might not consider me objective, Maalik, but keep in mind that you don’t really know who I am. The goal isn’t to be purely ‘objective’, it is to be integral, to consider things using ‘a framework that takes into account:
Subjective experiences, consciousness, thoughts, and emotions
Measurable, objective behaviors and biological or neurological functions
Shared culture, values, and relational meaning
and
Social systems, structures, technology, and economic forces’.
Integral is the name of the game if one’s goal is to truly integrate every point of view into your approach. I, We, It/Arts, Morals, Science/The Beautiful, the Good, the True/Subjective, Inter-Subjective, Objective; all different ways of saying the same thing.
My first self inquiry when considering any issue is ‘what are my preferences?’. I take answering that question very seriously. That’s because any ‘preferences’ on my part are exactly what need to be carefully examined and falsified if I am to arrive at an objective view.
I spend very little time on social media and online, in general. My posts are not ‘splash dash’ knee-jerk reactions to some post somewhere. I take weeks, sometimes months, to compose what goes on this blog, and you might have noticed I post very little. When I do, it’s commonly in response to having been specifically asked for my thoughts on issues. Many times, even when asked, I say nothing at all.
You have used Jim’s name to justify throwing Matt under the bus, and even deflect away from addressing the criticism from your own former colleagues, some of whom who have called out the contradictions in your own version of events.
Deflecting is something I do not do. Please elaborate on the criticisms from so-called “colleagues” and their stories of my “contradictions”.
So far as “throwing Matt under the bus”, that has not happened. I don’t ‘use Jim’s name’ in vain, I site his methodologies as the absolute basis of the connection we built with the audience. And I don’t do that lightly, by the way. I’ve committed decades to being a student of his approach, originally as a fan, then firsthand, followed by years with the various owners, and continuing to this day. Committing to making that study the core of my life’s work is the only true way to continue anything he originated. Otherwise, it’s just ‘masquerading in the master’s robes’.
I am the person who brought Matt into the Muppets at Disney. That’s why he’s there now. I am also the person subsequently responsible for seeing to it that Jerry Nelson was given the opportunity to designate Matt to inherit several of his characters before his death. In my opinion that is exactly what Matt should be graciously doing as the person Jerry trusted with his lineage, something I fully support. (I believe he should also be Gobo Fraggle…)
I have not thrown anyone under the bus, but many have stepped out into traffic all on their own by choosing ambition over integrity.
You have been dismissive of addressing constructive criticisms from anyone, including Marni Hill, someone who really went of her way to bat for you back in 2017.
You’re kidding, right? I’ve “dismissed” nothing and no one, especially Marni Hill. I‘m not dismissing you now even though I have ZERO obligation to engage with anyone (yourself included), as I regularly walk into a burning building without flinching as all the predatory trolls and lurkers gathered in the smoke to devour me.
While I truly welcome it, do you believe that your comment here is ‘constructive’, Maalik? It’s based upon broad speculative conjecture; conclusions, theories, and opinions formed from incomplete evidence and guesswork rather than established facts. And that’s OK, but understand that just because I am confident in my own knowledge-base beyond the broad criticisms of others, constructive or (more often) DEstructive, it doesn’t mean I don’t hear and respect their opinions. It means I have a different set of facts to which they have no access. I offer up some of those facts regularly to my own detriment and with little recognition by the reader.
I am not defending fans who have been rude to you, and I don’t care whether you did use AI or not; but this doesn’t excuse what are you doing, and it is not up to you to decide who the Muppets fans are.
You stated that you are “not defending fans who have been rude to (me)”. That is you deciding ‘who those Muppet fans are’ based upon your observation of their behavior. Is that up to you? I happen to think you are entitled to your opinions, just as I am. But while it will never be up to either of us to decide ‘who’ anybody is, it is up to them, and that is my point.
Jim was more than a guy who gave me a job, he was a friend whose personal and artistic integrity is something unique and precious that I will always champion. I am not asking to be excused for that, or anything. What do you believe it is that I am “doing” that in your mind would require excusal?
Even though here you seem to have some degree of animus towards me, Maalik, if you suspend that just for a moment is it really that hard to conceive that after nearly sixty years of immersion in the work of Jim Henson I might actually know what I’m talking about, and that might be perceived as threat enough for those who disregard Jim’s methods to want me out of the picture…?
My message remains ‘think for yourself and open your eyes to what is right in front of you instead of what you’ve been told to believe by those who benefit from influencing you, and those on the fringes’. If you can not tell me what it felt like when Jim Henson walked into the room from the point of view of his chosen family of creators, you are not authorized to tell me who he was by speaking as his proxy.
Further, if even co-creators have not taken the time to fully commit usage of firsthand experience to form views based upon injunction, apprehension, and confirmation, speaking from ‘hunches’ nets exactly what you are stating: solely objective preferential opinions rather than facts.
I’m not happy with how Disney has handled the Muppets…
As you may know, I avoid saying “Disney” this and that. “Disney” is just a corporate moniker behind which thousands of people stand, some acting with integrity, some without. When you say “Disney” hasn’t handled the Muppets to your liking, you let all of those individuals off the hook for being responsible. And it’s not just executives, it’s producers, writers, and, yes, performers, that have no understanding of Jim’s influence, or worse, sense it, but ignore it.
…but you are not helping things at all.
Define “things”. My goal has consistently been to do all that I can to insure that Jim Henson’s legitimate influence be kept alive and evolving. The Muppets are beyond being helped. I am sorry to say that they will never again rest upon Jim’s creative ideals because what it would take to see a course correction of such magnitude will never happen.
Maalik Naiem
Okay, if you want me to blame specific people for ruining the Muppets, I do blame Bob Iger in particular for leaving them to rot.
I could care less about the current state of the Muppets, and I am not out to prove whether I am “right” over you regarding Jim or not. I am no fool, and how dare you suggest I am, and I never demanded you are obligated to listen to me. But you don’t seem to realize you are alienating a lot of people with your approach. My “animus” against you comes from the fact I used to view you as a hero, and I am disappointed to see you seemingly go against people like Matt who were supposed to be your friends.
Do you want me to give specific names of former colleagues who have called you out? Let’s see… Brian Henson, Tyler Bunch, Rick Lyon, Bill Barretta, Cheryl Henson, Lisa Henson, David Stephens, etc.
Steve Whitmire
Okay, if you want me to blame specific people for ruining the Muppets, I do blame Bob Iger in particular for leaving them to rot.
OK. But this is not about “blaming specific people”. It’s about recognizing who is responsible rather than referring to a corporate entity. You strike me as someone who really thinks about this stuff, and it’s about your thinking and perspective. IO want to help it becomes more clear.
If you want to go with the old adage “the buck stops here”, then, yes, it’s all Bob Iger’s fault. But what you don’t know is that Iger gave the various executives working under him a great deal of autonomy within their particular departments, something that, as an executive, is likely greatly appreciated. That includes those who oversaw the Muppets, and those who oversaw them; many layers existed between Bob and the Muppets.
Sure, Bob may be responsible for an overall corporate culture, but his dealings directly with the day-to-day running of the Muppets were minimal. Could he have gotten more involved? Could he have demonstrated a willingness to sit with me for half an hour and gain a better understanding of how he could facilitate securing the Muppet’s longevity? Yes, and he chose not to do that.
I could care less about the current state of the Muppets, and I am not out to prove whether I am “right” over you regarding Jim or not. I am no fool, and how dare you suggest I am, and I never demanded you are obligated to listen to me. But you don’t seem to realize you are alienating a lot of people with your approach.
Maalik, if I thought you were a fool I would’ve never responded to you because I do not suffer them. I am having a discussion with you because I think you really want to understand all sides of the issue of which you speak. Those who are alienated by facing a realistic accounting of what it is that constitutes the depth of the connection with the audience present within the work we did with Jim were never truly connected in the first place. At the least they have no concept of why.
I think you do care about the current state of the Muppets. I think you don’t know what to believe because you’ve only heard one side of the story. Thus…:
My “animus” against you comes from the fact I used to view you as a hero, and I am disappointed to see you seemingly go against people like Matt who were supposed to be your friends.
First, I have no interest in being a “hero”. Casting me as such for yourself was your first mistake (I say that with a smile). It means you built an expectation of who you believe me to be, and in turn have become disillusioned by your own myth. That’s ok.
My question for you is, “why did you initially choose to view me as a “hero” in the first place?. I’d truly love to know.
Do you want me to give specific names of former colleagues who have called you out? Let’s see… Brian Henson, Tyler Bunch, Rick Lyon, Bill Barretta, Cheryl Henson, Lisa Henson, David Stephens, etc.
There names are a legion, and I knew the list you would use when I asked. That is why I wrote in our last exchange: ‘think for yourself and open your eyes to what is right in front of you instead of what you’ve been told to believe by those who benefit from influencing you, and those on the fringes’.
MichaelSar
Rick Lyon was, from what I’ve heard, fired from “Sesame Street” because he read David Rudman’s personal notes without his permission and was literally swiping ideas for a show and characters that David was working on from it. I don’t consider him trustworthy.
David Stephens’ claims were full of holes (Steve was apparently so against having somebody else perform Ernie but didn’t have a problem with John Tartaglia doing Ernie for “Play With Me Sesame”? Or John Kennedy doing Ernie for one of the Sesame Workshop Benefit Galas?), insulted Billy Barkhurst by calling him a patsy, and I found his straight-up saying that his Kermit “sounded right” and Matt Vogel’s didn’t far more arrogant than anything Steve has said on his blog. So I don’t consider him a trustworthy source either.
As for Brian Henson and his sisters, I’m not going to immediately believe everything they say simply because they’re Hensons. There have been less-than-flattering rumors flying around about Brian too.
Steve Whitmire
Appreciate your thinking this through….
Maalik Naiem
I am not a fan of David Stephens’ attitude either. It quite insulting of him to speak of Billy Barkhurst in that manner. But it is also obvious to me that Steve feels the same way about Billy as he does about Matt now, which I don’t think it is fair to either of them. We don’t even know what Steve thought regarding being replaced on “Play With Me Sesame,” but that is another part of this story that I have questioned regarding what went on (even while I was still supportive of Steve). This situation where I find myself disillusioned with everyone speaking out. Billy is also the only person who spoke out in this debacle during this year I felt provided a fair view of the entire situation. https://www.reddit.com/r/Muppets/comments/1r6e15y/former_henson_puppeteer_shares_video_from_when_he/?utm_source=embedv2&utm_medium=post_embed&utm_content=post_title&embed_host_url=https%3A%2F%2Fmuppetcentral.com%2Fforum%2Fthreads%2Fnew-and-very-interesting-post-from-steve-whitmire.67251%2Fpage-3
I have nothing more to say on this topic now.
Andrew Kay
In other words, you take David Stephens post about Steve and Billy (which is quite personal, explicit, and can be described as defamation), and it is “obvious” to you that Steve “feels the same way” about them, based on the fact… that he never said anything personal about either? Uh-oh.
Note that, unlike his opponents, Steve never demeans anyone personally in his posts, and pointedly limits his critical comments specifically to the Muppets authenticity (which we are loosing now, for various reasons, agree?), wrong executive decisions (being the main reasons for that), and the identifiability of Kermit performance (which we are losing now as well, mainly because of lack of proper transition). No insults or defamation to Matt or any other performer.
As for actual reality of the current relationship between Steve and other established Muppet performers (and for some great Muppets stories, too), check out a very recent video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OT4o6lFa41U
Maalik Naiem
You misinterpreted me. I said Steve feels the same way about Billy as he does about Matt, I was not making any comparison to what David said. Given Steve’s stance on Kermit being gone forever under Matt, it’s not a stretch to think he feels the same way about Billy and Peter Linz regarding Ernie.
I have already buried the hatchet with Steve over this, so what I said before is moot. I acknowledge I should been more tactful in how I presented my points.
Steve Whitmire
All good, Maalik. Just to clarify, there’s a difference in ‘feeling the same way about Billy or Peter as I do about Matt’, and feeling similarly about Ernie as I do about Kermit, or any of the rest of the Muppets, for that matter. I don’t know Billy at all. I do know Peter fairly well, much longer than Matt.
My conclusions are about the Muppets as a whole and the profound lose of Jim Henson’s vital influence. It just so happens that I performed Kermit in Jim’s wake, and that particular character draws particular focus. It is the Muppets for which I grieve. The performers, who they are as individuals, and the extent of their complicity is a separate issue.
Maalik Naiem
Thank you for your response, Steve. When I said “you feel the same way about Billy as Matt,” I meant that in regards to the characters. Again, that is moot now, I have changed my stance on that, and it wasn’t the best way to phrase my critique.
MichaelSar
I think I worded the point about John Kennedy and John Tartaglia doing Ernie wrong. David’s main point seemed to be that Steve supposedly “blacklisted” him from “Sesame Street” because he attempted to become an “understudy” for Ernie (though I honestly don’t think he just wanted to be an understudy, I think he wanted to replace Steve as Ernie entirely, mostly because he was still holding a grudge against Steve over the “One Muppet, One Voice” thing). Considering that both Johns continue to work on “Sesame Street” to this day*, if Steve did have a problem with either of them doing Ernie, he clearly didn’t attempt to get them fired from the show entirely. If he and the other puppeteers really didn’t like David Stephens, I doubt it was simply because David wanted to do Ernie.
* There WAS a gap between Seasons 36 and 43, if IMDB is to be believed, where John didn’t work on the show, but he returned to the show in 2012, when Steve was still doing Ernie, so I see no reason to believe whatever reasons he had for not working on the show were because of Steve (not to mention John said he was a fan of Steve’s in an interview with the Muppet Mindset, so there’s that).
Steve Whitmire
This notion of ‘blacklisting’ people on Sesame Street is absurd. My time on Sesame Street was unlike that of every other performer in that I would only come in to shoot for less than a week per season. We would bank all of the bits with Ernie and Bert in a few days time.
My point is that I was never involved in any of the day to day production, shooting, or especially the politics, of the show. I had ZERO influence over any decisions that were made, particularly about performers. While I never avoided expressing my feelings (that having multiple performers in a singular character role or casting performers who have no foundation in the origins of a character completely decimates that character), I could have never had control over who was cast as Ernie – I simply wasn’t involved in the series enough to have any substantive influence.
I have not read anything that David has written about any of this, so I cannot judge the context or validity of his comments. As far as I remember I only met him once at The Center for Puppetry Arts, and I don’t recollect ever working with him at all. There was certainly no opportunity for there to have been any competition between us for any role with the Muppets.
But I can say that on many occasions, new performers who desperately craved being a core part of the Muppets, but who at a the same time had almost no chance of seeing it happening, looked for anything on which they could blame their having not gotten a particular role. I had no idea I was being blamed, and had no involvement in whether or not David had any role within any branch of the Muppets.
My guess is that there simply wasn’t enough work to go around.
Maalik Naiem
There was a period time during the late 1990s and early 2000s where you seemed to be involved in Sesame Street materail more often (Ernie and even Kermit made some street scene appearances during that time, plus the “Journey to Ernie” segments with Matt as Big Bird, as well as productions like “CinderElmo” and “The Adventures of Elmo in Grouchland”). But yes, other than that, your work on the show was pretty much limited to the Bert and Ernie inserts.
I do understand where you coming from better now, and it was intriuging to hear your perspective on David Stephens.
Steve Whitmire
Yeah, there was Journey to Ernie and CinderElmo, etc. Those were still very short stays in New York with little involvement in the production.
I deeply loved being able to carry Jim’s influence forward through Ernie AND Kermit. Being on Sesame Street was like stepping into something ‘magical’ for me as my ten year old self. Like many things in life, what we build up as magical in our minds can become crushed under the weight of reality, and often those realities go one to outweigh the magic for the actual overall object of our love. Sesame as it was is gone. Jim’s influence at the core of the things he created is gone. Time has marched on with no in a position of authority willing to consider that it would be really good to do what it would take to bring any of that back to the world.
The irony is that the reason those now making behind the production of what started so long ago are there because of there initial love for the now missing magic…
Maalik Naiem
Those productions happened before David Stephens was involved, I just wanted to point that out.
I would agree the magic from “Sesame Street” is gone. I haven’t kept up much with the show in recent years, but the show has become more watered down and hyper focused on certain characters like Elmo or Abby Cadabby. I’m not happy with how things been with the Muppets either in recent years. I was turned off with what was done in the 2015 ABC series in partciular
Andrew Kay
‘You could never teach other people anything that mattered. The important things they had to learn for themselves, almost always by making mistakes, so that the lessons arrived too late to help. Experience was in that sense useless. It was precisely what could not be passed along in a lesson.‘ -Kim Stanley Robinson
‘I cannot teach anybody anything, I can only make them think.’ –Socrates
I totally understand IGAMA (It’s Green And Moves Around) crowd. They are many and getting more numerous the more people miss the originals. They really love the Muppets. They watch The Muppet Show and the Muppet movies, they look forward to be enchanted by The Muppet Christmas Carol every year. They want more Muppets in their life, they want new Muppets productions, and they want their Muppets so much that they do not mind if the Muppets are not the same anymore. For all they care, (*any character, it can happen to any of them*) can start hopping around, talking in high pitched Mickey Mouse voice, and act like that too. It doesn’t really matter — as long as everybody accepts it without complaining too much, it’s the price they are ready to pay.
What is hard for them to realize is that the “updated” Muppets would miss the original Muppets appeal, and that “gee it looks like the original” excitement can quickly fade away into “meh not as good as it was”. But you cannot explain that beforehand, just as you cannot quite pass your feel for authenticity, the experience of actually working with Jim, and all sorts of things that need to echo some part of one’s own life in order to be understood properly.
IMHO, you have to _let it fail_ to get this point across to IGAMA people. It seems things are too far gone to mend on the fly, so something like that needs to happen in order for fans, managers, and even performers to start thinking about what Muppets really are and why people love them so much. Until then, it is easy for people to ignore criticism and skew things around in their mind into thinking of anyone voicing critical opinions as an obstacle in the way between them and the great Muppet productions.
Muppets are not the same anymore. It is certainly not my place to ask, but, in the meantime, i cannot help wishing that we could get more of your observations on the way the Muppets *were* before things started to go sour, the hidden treasures and revelations in the same vein as The Muppet Guys Talking that could be used to keep alive the good things that Jim brought to this world (eventually, by the people so minded), rather than focusing more on how it came about that the current state of things misses all that. We’ve been already watching it slowly creep in since 2009. =)
As for AI, neo-Luddites will always appear when some drastic change affects the way things are done. People who suffer from that the most are mainly not the true artists looking for the depth of artistic expression rather than the means, but craftsmen plying the products of their trade being replaced by machinery. Sad and unfortunate as it is, the only way forward is to embrace the changes and find the ability to adjust or modify their trade to survive.
@Mr Naiem, if i may, humanity always had that unique ability to be persuaded by slogans. A good slogan makes us postpone the critical thinking and go along — which is good, since if not for that, all of us would still be sitting in the trees instead of building pyramids, going to space, and taking money to the banks. Respectfully, though, before you get in the mode of thinking that Steve is “throwing everybody under the bus”(Rick) or start considering him as some stranger who was “working alongside the Muppets”(Joe), please take a moment to reflect on what you already knew about Steve, things he has done for the Muppets, consider the details of what exactly he says in his posts, and where his knowledge of the Muppets originally comes from, firsthand. =)
Maalik Naiem
Hi Mr. Kay,
Just to be clarify,
I am not a fan of Joe Hennes at all, and I did also call him out for his blog post about what Steve has been saying. I am well aware of what Steve has said and done for the Muppets, and I used to be a supporter of Steve myself; however I don’t appreciate his attitude; just because I believe the Muppets are a lost cause doesn’t mean I agree this should aired out publicly in this manner. There has been plenty of people who have called out Steve in a harsher and more disingenuous manner than I have. I tried to give him the benefit of the doubt at first, but I just let myself crack under the pressure of seeing more of his former colleagues call him out this time.
Andrew Kay
Bill actually admitted to being a true fan of Steve in his reply to comments under his own critical post, check it out. (Love Bill!) I’m sure that the interpretation of what he said in his post varies wildly from podcaster to podcaster, and some of these people can get pretty vehement — emotional strain is what keeps their view counts growing. So i would take the whole thing with a big grain of salt. =)
As for the rest, nothing changed much from original Pundit time, certainly not for worse. Remember the incomparable Mr or Ms Fleece Throat? I’m pretty sure that this person, or somebody very close to them either is or will be on your list of names, should you continue. Everybody said what they should for the reasons they have, now and then, nothing new here.
Myself, i most sincerely hope that the Muppets are not done in yet. They survived 70 years and it was not all bed of roses either. I hope they will be able to overcome the hard times (again) and survive 70 more, and then some. If some harsh words from somebody who really knows what he talks about can help to put them back on track, i’m all for it — Frank does not quite mince words when it comes to that either.
Cheers!
Maalik Naiem
I remember Fleece Throat as well. What that person did was not acceptable at all, I do still agree on that. Frank may not mince words when it comes to he views how the Muppets, but I feel he comes as off as more diplomatic in his responses, and he acts respectful to Eric and his work taking over for his characters.
I am not saying Steve is obligated to give his approval to Matt performing Kermit, but giving him some pointers would be more helpful than making these claims that Kermit is gone forever in his blog posts.
I still agree with some of the basics that Steve emphasizes in his posts, but my point is despite how horrible Disney is as a corporation, I am questioning if Steve is really being truthful of why he was really fired.
Steve Whitmire
“Truthfulness” means that I am to the best of my knowledge stating what I believe to be truth. All I have to go on is what was stated directly to me when I asked prior to all the equivocation, half-truths, and outright defamation manufactured to assassinate my character. I have always been truthful.
I am in pre-production right now and have limited time to devote to blogging, so at this juncture I will say three things:
Most on your list lacked a consistent relationship with Jim at the core of the team.
The relationship between parent and child creates a dynamic that persists through life, and it is drastically different from an unencumbered one between a mentor and his chosen apprentices.
‘Think for yourself and open your eyes to what is right in front of you instead of what you’ve been told to believe by those who benefit from influencing you, and those on the fringes’.
Andrew Kay
@Mr Naiem:
As for ‘I am questioning if Steve is really being truthful of why he was really fired‘:
Really, come on. When separation happens like that, they usually do not go into exact reasons. It is mostly something like “your services are no longer needed” or “did not meet position requirements” or “business misconduct” instead of “that’s because of that thing you said to VP at the last cocktail party”. Note that neither the person NOR the remaining coworkers get the detailed explanation, and mostly have to revert to guesses and office rumors like “maybe because he is related to…” or “likely he was actually…” or “i think a year ago i saw him in the parking lot with…” and that grows into office conspiracy theories. Nobody but the actual people who made the decision knows the exact truth. People have theories, more or less plausible, but not the whole truth. The only thing the rest of us can be sure of is that somebody in higher position really wanted him gone.
Since that happened, many fans came to conclusion that they can sleep better if they convince themselves to lay all blame for what happened to Kermit on Steve, and were looking for reasons to believe that. Well, i guess it works for people. The thing is, whatever it was, it could and should be handled differently — on executive side. When it got undesired publicity, the big names had to intervene to support the company image, as they should, and a few of the unhappy folks who had their dreams of becoming kermits broken by ‘One Muppet one voice” decision (all muppeteers stood for) saw their chance to voice their grief publicly.
To answer the next question these people usually ask, “why did Steve blacklist the puppeteers”, the answer is, he didn’t. It’s been answered many times since 2017, he simply was NOT in position to be able do this, even if he wanted to.
(Looking at Mr Fleece Throat, I would happily blacklist some myself, but it was ‘One Muppet one voice’ and shift in studio priorities undercutting the available spots, really.)
“As for the multi-casting idea, we all went against it back when the Muppets were first sold to Disney. Not just Steve, we did it together.“(Bill)
“Interesting that the biggest kickbacks/arguments are from people who have “worked” Kermit or wanted to do the role. Figures…“(Mike)
MichaelSar
It’s also worth noting that Artie Esposito and Brett O’Quinn both worked with the Muppets after the “multi-casting” idea was scrapped (Brett worked on the Lady Gaga special and “Muppets Most Wanted”). I’ve always thought that threw a wrench in the “blacklisting” claims.
Andrew Kay
Re ‘I am not saying Steve is obligated to give his approval to Matt performing Kermit, but giving him some pointers would be more helpful than making these claims that Kermit is gone forever’:
I am actually with you on this one.
It would be a dream of mine to have Steve work with Matt, to have Frank save some time in his schedule to advise Eric, or, even better, have Matt buy a ticket, and pop up on Steve’s doorstep with a pack of Bud, saying ‘hey man, i’m sorry it all played out this way, how can i be of help?’.
That would be my dream come true.
Unfortunately, life rarely works this way. There are lot of things, business, family, expenses, personal stuff, and plain good old money issues, always getting in the way of something good.
THERE IS a way to keep real Kermit alive and pass him on as the real live entity, which Steve outlined in this blog. Unfortunately, it involves Matt actually working with Steve at Kermit for years, slowly soaking the things about the character that cannot be quite expressed in words. Just the way Matt did with Jerry — why do you think these characters are so good?
Having a Q&A session and performance hints here and there will help, but then, looking from character authenticity point of view, we would still have a substitute, a masterful stand-in, instead of authentic continuation of character.
IMHO, a really good substitute would still be better than nothing, better to give them a _chance_ to find some way of their own to pay respects and maybe continue afresh what Jim started, rather than having the Muppets just end. Especially if we know for sure that whoever makes these decisions is still vehemently opposed to having real Kermit return to the Muppets, for whatever reasons it might be.
After all, nobody lives forever, and sooner or later something like that will come to all characters, in some form. (Which actually CAN become a real character transition under proper circumstances! — see Steve’s posts here).
But had it occurred to you that Steve might not be ready to see that real, authentic essence of Kermit that he was collecting by crumbs all his life just disappear, while there is still some ghost of a chance to save him and pass him along to live on? That Steve still has to go through the grieving process of his own (much stronger than me and you, believe me) before he can let it happen? It is his friend, his mentor, his hero, and all of his life we are talking about here, after all.
Maalik Naiem
And by the way, the “fans” mention I made regarding people who are rude to you was an error on my part; I never meant to suggest I can decide who the Muppets fans are.
Steve Whitmire
And by the way, the “fans” mention I made regarding people who are rude to you was an error on my part; I never meant to suggest I can decide who the Muppets fans are.
Honestly, I disagree with you on that. It’s not about your deciding who they Muppet fans are, it’s about you (and many others) forming an opinion on who some of them might be based upon witnessing their behavior. I think you have every reason to form that judgement, and I support you in doing so.
I say this as a constructive comment because I think you are trying to reconcile something that you DO, in fact, care about: from here, it looks as though you are spending effort looking for things about which to be offended. But I think you are just in search of reconciliation.
Steve Whitmire
I dreamt of Jim and Jane last night for the first time in a while. The whole “birthday thing” is SO on the back burner of my thinking that it is hardly there. I don’t do big celebratory birthdays for myself, and there is SO much more that I celebrate about Jim than the day he was born.
I’m stating that to say that it’s not like any of that has been in my conscious thinking, you know?; nothing that I would have thought would have sparked my subconscious to plant Jim in my thoughts today any more than any other day.
But there he was, alive and fully himself, Jane standing near him in a wooded area, and while the encounter felt longer, it was what he said that stuck. He said to me, “When I teach you something, I will do it quietly…”.
I am not a ‘keep the Muppets around at all costs’ person, and for me “all costs” are the exploitation that is happening now by people who do so for their own gain with little or no regard for where it all came from, and no firsthand knowledge in the mix. Jim was a person, not a legendary mythological figure who can be studied to a point that nets a vessel. His influence could’ve actually been included at the core of it all, but that will never happen now…too many players that benefit from that not happening.
I never once had any conversation with Jim about Kermit. Keeping that a living legacy (what I call the “lineage”) isn’t about giving pointers, or sitting down over a beer to open-mindedly talk character, and it goes beyond ruminating in someone’s presence for years. Even the most talented person has to be the right person, someone with the willingness to give themselves over to work in service of someone else’s vision for life, someone who can say “that’s enough for me” because it fills them with joy to do so. No one involved at any level is willing to put there own ambition aside and do that.
It’s not about talent – Matt has that – it’s that there isn’t such a thing as a talent for literally inhabiting another person. Too much foundational material goes into that coincidence, a lifetime of it. And without it there is no literal cloning of the soul.
Andrew Kay
I think it is right and proper to go with what Jim tells you in your heart — you knew him like none of us ever will. Most of us have only guesses and projections of our own desires to go by, after all. Knowing that neither you nor anyone visiting this site is ‘kill the Muppets at all costs’ person either — let life run its course. If the Muppets (as a whole, old characters and new) won’t be able to keep that original spark that makes them the Muppets, no amount of ‘at all costs’ efforts would help anyway.
Happy Birthday and All the Best Wishes to you and Jim!
Amanda
I truly believe Jim and Jane paid you a visit Steve. The fact that you dreamt about Jim on both you and his birthday wasn’t just a coincidence. That sounds like something Jim would of said. I would pay attention to those words because I truly believe it was a sign. I don’t know what but I believe he wants to tell you something important. Thank you for sharing your dream with us Steve. I always enjoy hearing about your dreams. You remind me of myself and the way I dream. I usually see someone or something in my dream before it or something similar happens later on in my life. Pay attention to your dreams because they are messages. Happy belated birthday to you and Jim Steve! Cheers to celebrating another cherished year of life hear on Earth and many more years to come! Best wishes!
Steve Whitmire
Darrell,
Your comments concerning “JOIE” were, in my judgement, entirely constructive, well-meaning, and actually helpful. Please be assured that nothing written in response was intended directly towards you, and that your comments were, in fact, appreciated!
I never like to ignore anyone’s point of view, and I spend a lot of time working on reconciling any issue with multiple perspectives. I do that in the sincere belief that everyone holds some piece of the truth, and most issues could be resolved if all were less polarized. Once in a while, the reconciliation requires choosing a particular side of an issue as what evidently presents the greatest good for the greatest span.
Your thoughts are always welcome!
-S
Darrell
Hello, Steve. I would like to say that I am one of the commenters who wrote a lengthy comment regarding Mirth & Mischief’s use of AI. I am usually a timid person who often gets intimidated out of my own perspective by opposing parties looking to undermine me. All of that is a bit personal, but it is to reinforce the point that I often consider it “not worth it” to engage in certain discussions. I have been working to correct my cowardice in all aspects of life, a long and ongoing process. I chose to respond to your post (even though you’re not the one who made the images or runs the event) because after meeting you in the house of mouse expo (Green suit & Kermit Puppet) and tangentially learning about you through various interviews and media, that I could be confident you would take my comment in good faith. For lack of a better phrase, I trusted you to be able to have that conversation. I also intend no ill will towards the event or it’s staff as I have hopefully well established within that comment chain.
This post likely pertains to a lot of people, so the notion that you would solely make one on my account is ridiculous, though I sincerely hope my attempt to clarify my concerns and educate did not come off as condescending or offensive in any way. I use to lack any understanding of the larger AI problem, the consumption in comparison to other technologies, it’s consistent informational errors, it’s gradual outsourcing of people’s comprehension and it being built upon people’s unconsented and stolen works to train itself. I do hate the fact that platforms that I use often, Youtube, Instagram and even my own employer have integrated AI.
I should clarify I am exclusively and only referring to generative AI, as are a lot of the people that are understandably concerned. A computer player running circles around me in a game of Mario Kart would not demonstrate the same harm, nor would your smartwatch saying it’s preprogrammed “Good morning, Steve Whitmire!” each day, that would simply be primitive AI following programming, not the monstrous generative AI that often requires massive data centers. I’m sure you are aware of this but it is important to make my distinction. I was not aware that there were data centers looking to optimize it’s environmental effects and I do agree that as justifiably upsetting as some of these things are, it is more practical to uplift the companies that are making the positive changes as opposed to an all-out, nondescript boycott.
I will definitely look into these things to further my own knowledge and perspective on the topic. Another reason I spoke from an informative and friendly tone (Which hopefully came through as intended) is because my own father and different people I’ve encountered have taken things made with AI at face value unknowingly and without malicious intent. Therefore, I find it important to try the amicable approach to see their intent first prior to needlessly escalating, as I see FAR too often online. It’s equivalent to breaking down the door with a bat as opposed to simply trying the handle, or using a grenade on a fly instead of looking for the swatter. I sincerely appreciate the sincerity with which you engage with people since it is often far too easy for bad actors to simply ignore criticisms or deflect.
My initial reaction to this leaned towards disappointment and confusion. Disappointment at you potentially endorsing AI, and confusion at the self-indulgent, knee jerk notion that this could be a blunt response to me. After evaluating the post, your responses to others in this comment section as well as your prior direct responses to me, I would like to think that neither are the case. Thanks.
Maalik Naiem
I am just going to say, Steve, I took a bit more time to think about what you said, and I get it now. I just snapped under the pressure, and I was torn on who to believe. I am sorry for causing a public confrontation. I may not agree with the way you chose to go about it, but I understand your intentions were to express what was needed to be done to protect Kermit’s lineage. Farewell.